Sign in  

American Tax Consultants reviews and customer experiences

Help the community - share your experience with American Tax Consultants.

American Tax Consultants Reviews

• Feb 10, 2026

Got a call about back taxes from someone named Nancy.

I got a call from a number (855) 630-1737. The person said she was Nancy from American Tax Consultants. She started talking about back taxes, saying they sent notices. It was all "blah, blah, blah."

I never heard of them. I don't have any back taxes I know about. The whole thing felt off. It was just a random call out of nowhere.

• Feb 10, 2026

Got a weird voicemail about taxes from someone named Nancy

I got a voicemail from a woman saying she was Nancy from American Tax Consultants. She told me to call back right away about some missing tax filings. The number she left was (707) 926-8542.

I don't know who this is. I never heard of them. The whole thing felt off, so I didn't call back. I just wanted to put this out there in case someone else gets the same message.

• Feb 04, 2026

Tricked into paying $500 for tax service I didn't want

I got a call telling me to call this number to get my AGI PIN for my 2025 tax return on FreeTax NY. The woman said the only way she could retrieve my PIN was to override the system. So I gave her my information. I emailed my tax return, license number, and even my picture.

I asked her why she needed all that, and she just said she was overriding the PIN. I thought I could then go back to my Free Tax New York form and bypass the pin. At the end, I e-signed everything without reading that she charged me almost $500 to do my taxes, which I never wanted done. She tricked me into the whole thing.

Now I'm only getting back $200 from Federal, when it was supposed to be over $900 through Free Tax New York. I'm extremely upset. I worked hard for that money and I needed it. That company tricks people and takes money for services they didn't ask for.

• Jan 23, 2026

Got a weird voicemail about back taxes from a Nancy

I got a voicemail message from someone named Nancy at American Tax Consultants. She said it was about back taxes and missed filings on my account. The message said this might be their only attempt to reach me and that I needed to call right away.

She left a number, 707-926-8542, and said to call to be removed from something. The whole thing felt off. I never got any notice from them before this. The voicemail said to call back the number on my caller ID and press 8, but I didn't recognize that number either. I didn't call them back.

Check fields!

Write a review about American Tax Consultants


Upload here Increase visibility and credibility of your review by
adding a photo, document or video
Submit

American Tax Consultants Contacts

If you know any contact information for American Tax Consultants, help other users by adding it.

Add new contacts
| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z | New